Managing Automation :: Technology Solutions for Progressive Manufacturers Sign in or register  |  Advertise |  Subscribe to MA Magazine  | Newsletters |   My Profile

Managing Automation® Magazine

Editorial from the August 2007 issue of Managing Automation

Best of Breed: One Size Doesn't Always Fit All

                                  Digg This Article   Add to Delicious

Abstract:Though manufacturers show a preference for packaged software suites, SOA's promise of flexible integration and users' desire for full feature sets are keeping the door open for best-of-breed applications.
Relevant Links:

Back in 2000, when Uponor Corp., an international supplier of plumbing and heating systems, opted for the Oracle packaged application suite, it did so because it wanted a platform to which it could add modules from that same vendor when and where it made sense. When warehouse management became a core requirement, Uponor figured it was a no-brainer to plug in Oracle Corp.'s WMS product because Uponor was already covered for the license.

Turned out, that decision wasn't so black-and-white. For Uponor's purposes, the Oracle WMS didn't hold its own in a feature-to-feature comparison with best-of-breed applications specializing in that particular area of functionality, according to Chris Moore, vice president of IT for 1.5 billion euro Uponor. Yet, integrating a third-party WMS application with the core Oracle enterprise suite was likely to open a Pandora's box of integration headaches.

In the end, concerns about integration took a back seat to the need for high-end features, such as order consolidation functionality. In 2004, the Finland-based company added HighJump Software's WMS offering to its core Oracle ERP platform.

[Click to continue]