MES Short Lists Feature Plex, FlexNet, Even HighJump and SAP

Manufacturing execution systems (MES) software is a market beseiged on all sides by vendors of every stripe, but new data shows that buyers still rate the manufacturing software high on their evaluation lists.


Looking for Manufacturing Execution Systems (MES) solutions?
Compare Products Now
Companies Mentioned
Posted on Jun 17, 2010

Almost from the start, the terrain of manufacturing execution systems, or MES, was ripe for invasion. MES is a breed of manufacturing software that sits between the enterprise resource planning (ERP) system and the people and systems that create products on the manufacturing floor. Part scheduler, part traffic cop between the production world and the enterprise, MES has long held something of a “betwixt and between” status in the pantheon of manufacturing software.

In a recent report whose title speaks volumes — “Is the MES Market Perpetually Inert or Prone to Capitalize on Emerging Product Supply Requirements?” — AMR Research/Gartner analyst Simon Jacobson wrote, “Multiple software classes seek to capitalize on this [MES] opportunity. Application boundaries are blurring, with pressure from enterprise and factory automation providers mounting.”

Manufacturing software buyers don’t seem the least bit deterred by the vendor maneuvering, however. Registered users of TechMATCH, ManagingAutomation.com’s free product selection tool, consistently rank manufacturing execution systems among the most desired enterprise software packages. Still, when we dove beneath the headlines and into the usage statistics for TechMATCH, what we found lent credence to AMR’s point: There’s a world of diversity in the MES market, and the vendor names that surface underscore how traditional lines are blurring in this hotly contested territory.

Below is a list of the 10 MES products most often selected for side-by-side comparison by ManagingAutomation.com users — a proxy for the software packages that are showing up on manufacturers’ software short lists. Each product in the list below has a link to its TechMATCH profile page, where you can find more information about the offering and dive deeper into the MES landscape with some comparisons of your own.

The Top 10 Most Compared MES Products in TechMATCH:

  • 1. Plex Online, from Plex Systems
  • 2. FlexNet, from Apriso
  • 3. HighJump Manufacturing Advantage
  • 4. Proficy HMI/SCADA-CIMPLICITY, from GE Intelligent Platforms
  • 5. SIMATIC IT, from Siemens
  • 6. Solumina, by iBASEt
  • 7. SAP Business ByDesign
  • 8. FactoryTalk VantagePoint EMI, by Rockwell Automation
  • 9. SAP's Visiprise Manufacturing Execution
  • 10. Lawson’s M3 Enterprise Management System
  • To get started in TechMATCH, check out an MES product comparison that gives you an insider’s view of some of the leading solutions for manufacturers.

    BUZZ METER: What's popular on the site right now

    Ask The Manufacturing Execution Systems Expert

    • TechMATCH Showcase

      Business Intelligence

      Infor ERP VISUAL

      More than 4,000 businesses use Infor ERP VISUAL because of its affordability, deep end-to-end functionality, lower total cost of ownership, flexibility, and ease of use.

      Discovery for Warranty and Support

      High warranty costs and customer dissatisfaction with poor quality products are challenges that manufacturing executives cannot ignore. Getting the information required to identify warranty issues before you’re at risk requires visibility across the entire supply chain, which most organizations to date struggle to achieve. The key to success is obtaining a unified view of all necessary data, and enabling users to correlate problems with root causes.

      Process Industries for Microsoft Dynamics AX

      Process Industries for Microsoft Dynamics AX is an ERP system designed for mid-to-large enterprises. It helps process manufacturers better manage all the variables required to engineer and build products to custom specifications, optimize capacity, comply with regulatory demands, and drive continuous process improvement. Ideal for food, beverage, life sciences, pharmaceuticals, primary metals, specialty chemicals, pulp and paper manufacturers and distributors.

    • TechMATCH Showcase

      Customer Relationship Management

      Plex Online

      The company's flagship product, Web-hosted Plex Online, connects and manages the total manufacturing process. Plex Online is the first true on-demand manufacturing performance system - delivering real-time interface for a finer degree of control. With the ability to manage a single facility or an entire enterprise, Plex Online allows manufacturers to know anything about the operation, anywhere, at anytime.

      Lean Enterprise for Microsoft Dynamics AX

      Lean Enterprise for Microsoft Dynamics AX is a fully integrated global Enterprise Resource Planning (ERP) system that combines traditional manufacturing and distribution functions with powerful Lean capabilities to deliver true performance improvement to manufacturing organizations. With solutions for Financial Management, Supply Chain Management, Manufacturing, CRM, and Human Resources, Lean Enterprise for Microsoft Dynamics AX can help your organization eliminate waste, increase throughput, shorten lead times, and improve quality levels, leading to increased customer satisfaction and higher overall profitability levels.

      Green Beacon LightShip

      Green Beacon provides enterprise software systems, including selections from the Microsoft Dynamics family of business applications, as well as analytics tools, CompassPoint solutions and a variety of other technologies depending on the customer’s needs. Utilizing our LightShip implementation and development methodology, we navigate our clients toward effective redefinition and documentation of established business processes, providing a rapid and substantial return on investment.

    • TechMATCH Showcase

      Enterprise Resource Planning

      Infor ERP SyteLine

      Infor ERP SyteLine helps companies connect manufacturing operations and core business processes with suppliers and customers. From repetitive to engineer-to-order, Infor ERP SyteLine facilitates the processes to accelerate production and meet customer demand more quickly.

      Discovery for Warranty and Support

      High warranty costs and customer dissatisfaction with poor quality products are challenges that manufacturing executives cannot ignore. Getting the information required to identify warranty issues before you’re at risk requires visibility across the entire supply chain, which most organizations to date struggle to achieve. The key to success is obtaining a unified view of all necessary data, and enabling users to correlate problems with root causes.

      Process Industries for Microsoft Dynamics AX

      Process Industries for Microsoft Dynamics AX is an ERP system designed for mid-to-large enterprises. It helps process manufacturers better manage all the variables required to engineer and build products to custom specifications, optimize capacity, comply with regulatory demands, and drive continuous process improvement. Ideal for food, beverage, life sciences, pharmaceuticals, primary metals, specialty chemicals, pulp and paper manufacturers and distributors.

    • TechMATCH Showcase

      Supply Chain Execution

      IFS Applications

      Throughout the world, IFS provides industry-focused software solutions that help leading companies to improve profitability, meet regulatory requirements, and take advantage of new business opportunities. IFS Applications, IFS' suite of more than 60 web-based components, is the only true component-based enterprise solution on the market, enabling companies to deploy the software step by step as their needs and budget dictate. Based on open standards, IFS Applications makes it easier to stay up-to-date with technology and to integrate with legacy systems. And only IFS offers total lifecycle management, helping companies maximize profitability over the lifecycles of their products, customers, and assets.

      Plex Online

      The company's flagship product, Web-hosted Plex Online, connects and manages the total manufacturing process. Plex Online is the first true on-demand manufacturing performance system - delivering real-time interface for a finer degree of control. With the ability to manage a single facility or an entire enterprise, Plex Online allows manufacturers to know anything about the operation, anywhere, at anytime. Plex Online is a powerful and flexible platform for supporting lean manufacturing principles within manufacturing organizations. Over 350 functional modules available using a simple Web browser. Plex Online includes shop floor control, traceability, quality management, EDI, accounting and many other capabilities configured as a fully integrated system or as a point solution.

      MAX

      Exact MAX is a proven ERP solution well-suited for food processors, medical device manufacturers and electronics manufactures. With powerful and flexible batch processing, part management, and production planning features, MAX is particularly well-adept at fulfilling the needs of contract service providers, but can also be successfully deployed in full-service manufacturing facilities. For companies in need of a user-friendly business system that can help them manage business processes from order-entry to production planning and on through to fulfillment, MAX is designed to fit the way you do business.